Have you ever wondered how new rose varieties make their way into your garden? Enter the world of rose trials - a fascinating process that sets the benchmark for rose excellence worldwide.

What Are Rose Trials?

Rose trials are rigorous evaluations of new rose varieties, and in some cases, re-assessments of older rose varieties that previously won awards. These trials compare the performance of roses under standardized conditions. These trials don't just judge the flower - they assess the entire plant over multiple years, typically two to four. The goal? To test roses in public gardens using methods similar to what a home gardener might employ.

During these trials, roses are judged on various aspects:
- Growth habit and vigor (25% of the score)
- Buds and flowers (20%)
- Recurrent bloom (20%)
- Disease resistance (25%)
- Fragrance (10%)

The Science Behind the Beauty

Rose trials adhere to strict scientific methods. Multiple bushes of each variety are planted together, allowing judges to evaluate grouped plantings rather than individual bushes. All roses grow in the same garden under identical conditions, ensuring fair comparisons.

A panel of respected rose experts, horticulturists, garden designers, and industry professionals judge the roses several times a year throughout the trial period. This thorough process ensures that the final scores reflect the roses' performance over time, not just a single season.

Red Garden Rose at the RHS AGM Red Rose trial in 2024, What Is a Rose Trial?
Red rose at the rose trial

Types of Rose Trials

1. National Rose Trials: Organized by national horticultural societies, these focus on evaluating new rose varieties within a specific country's climate.

2. International Rose Trials: These have a broader scope, assessing roses from around the world under different climatic conditions.

3. Specialized Trials: Some trials, like the RHS Rose Trial in the UK, evaluate roses for specific purposes, such as the best roses for British gardens.

Organizations Involved in Rose Trials

Several organizations worldwide conduct rose trials:

  • The Royal National Rose Society (RNRS): A leading authority on roses based in the UK.
  • American Rose Society (ARS): Organizes trials across various climatic regions in the United States.
  • World Federation of Rose Societies (WFRS): Coordinates global rose trials and sets evaluation standards.
  • National Rose Societies: Many countries have their own societies conducting trials tailored to their specific climates.
  • The Royal Horticultural Society (RHS): A leading horticultural institution in the United Kingdom, conducting regular plant trials, including specialized trials for roses.

The Royal Horticultural Society (RHS): Rose Trials

The RHS conducts comprehensive plant trials, including roses, at their gardens, notably Wisley. Their prestigious Award of Garden Merit (AGM) helps gardeners make informed choices about plants. The RHS rose trial lasts four years and evaluates various categories, including old garden roses, shrub roses, climbing roses, and hybrid teas.

The AGM is awarded only to plants meeting specific criteria:

  • Outstanding excellence for ordinary garden decoration or use
  • Availability in the market
  • Good constitution
  • No need for highly specialist growing conditions or care
  • No particular susceptibility to pests or diseases
  • No unreasonable degree of reversion in vegetative or floral characteristics

These criteria ensure that AGM plants are practical choices for home gardeners, whether they're cultivating roses, fruits, vegetables, or ornamental plants.

Red Rose Trial at the RHS Wisley garden for the AGM award, red rose trial in 2024, What Is a Rose Trial?
Red Rose Trial at the RHS Trial Garden

Unique Features of Different Trials

Some trials, like the Biltmore International Rose Trials in the US, allow public participation. Visitors can vote for their favorite roses, adding a delightful interactive element to the process.

Why Rose Trials Matter

Rose trials are crucial for several reasons:
1. They help identify superior varieties, guiding gardeners in their choices.
2. They promote rose breeding by recognizing outstanding new cultivars.
3. They contribute to preserving rose heritage by including historic varieties.
4. They enhance gardening knowledge by providing valuable data for growers and researchers.

Red Rose at the RHS AGM Red Rose trial in 2024, What Is a Rose Trial?
Red Rose at the RHS rose trial in one of the rose beds

Who Benefits from Rose Trials?

While rose enthusiasts and professionals certainly benefit from these trials, they're particularly valuable for everyday gardeners. The trials and awards like the AGM help novice gardeners make informed choices, potentially sparking a deeper interest in the world of roses.

In conclusion, rose trials are the unsung heroes of the gardening world, ensuring that only the cream of the crop makes it to your garden. So next time you're admiring a particularly stunning rose, remember - it likely earned its place in your garden through years of rigorous testing and evaluation!